2021-09-22 sec-litreleases litigation_release 67 KB 3,321 chars

SEC v. Karen Marie Michel; and Sweetwater Union High School District, No. LR-25215, Southern District of New York (Sept. 22, 2021) — Press Release

raw: Karen Marie Michel

Karen Marie Michel, No. LR-25215 (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 22, 2021)

Caption
SEC v. Karen Marie Michel, et al.
summary

The SEC charged the Sweetwater Union High School District and its former CFO, Karen Michel, with misleading investors during a $28 million municipal bond offering by providing false budget projections

paragraph

The SEC charged the Sweetwater Union High School District and its former CFO, Karen Michel, with misleading investors during a $28 million municipal bond offering by providing false budget projections. The defendants allegedly claimed the district would end the fiscal year with a $19.5 million surplus when it was actually facing a $7.2 million deficit due to significant deficit spending. Michel faces charges for violating Section 17(a)(3) of the Securities Act of 1933, and she agreed to a settlement including a $28,000 penalty and a ban from participating in future municipal securities offerings. The District consented to an order finding violations of Sections 17(a)(2) and 17(a)(3) and agreed to engage an independent consultant to evaluate its disclosure policies.

narrative

The SEC charged the Sweetwater Union High School District and its former CFO, Karen Michel, with misleading investors during a $28 million municipal bond offering by providing false budget projections. The defendants allegedly claimed the district would end the fiscal year with a $19.5 million surplus when it was actually facing a $7.2 million deficit due to significant deficit spending. Michel faces charges for violating Section 17(a)(3) of the Securities Act of 1933, and she agreed to a settlement including a $28,000 penalty and a ban from participating in future municipal securities offerings. The District consented to an order finding violations of Sections 17(a)(2) and 17(a)(3) and agreed to engage an independent consultant to evaluate its disclosure policies. The SEC charged the Sweetwater Union High School District and its former CFO, Karen Michel, with misleading investors in a $28 million municipal bond offering by submitting fraudulent budget projections that concealed significant deficit spending. Michel, who managed the offering, signed false certifications regarding the accuracy of these documents, which falsely indicated a positive fund balance instead of the actual negative $7.2 million position. Michel settled the charges by agreeing to a $28,000 penalty and an injunction barring her from future municipal securities offerings, while the school district consented to an order requiring an independent consultant to review its disclosure policies. Both parties settled without admitting or denying the allegations, resolving violations of Sections 17(a)(2) and 17(a)(3) of the Securities Act of 1933. The SEC charged the Sweetwater Union High School District and its former CFO, Karen Michel, with misleading investors in a $28 million municipal bond offering by falsely projecting a $19.5 million general fund balance, when the district was actually headed for a $7.2 million deficit. Michel, who managed the offering and signed certifications attesting to the accuracy of disclosures, knowingly omitted internal reports contradicting the projections and failed to account for actual expenses. The SEC alleged Michel violated Section 17(a)(3) of the Securities Act, while the district violated Sections 17(a)(2) and 17(a)(3). Michel settled without admitting guilt, agreeing to a permanent injunction from future municipal securities participation and a $28,000 penalty; Sweetwater agreed to retain an independent consultant to overhaul its disclosure policies. The settlement is pending court approval.

Enriched metadata

Scheme
financial-fraud (95%)
Court
Southern District of New York
Outcome
settled
Settlement
$28,000
Civil penalty
$28,000
Victim loss
$19,500,000
Entity
Karen Marie Michel
Classified financial-fraud(confidence 95%). EDGAR detection: forms 10-K/10-Q/8-K/NT 10-K· recall 67% / precision 23%. detection rule →
Parties
Securities and Exchange CommissionKaren Marie MichelSweetwater Union High School District
Keywords
michelsecsecuritieskaren mariemarie michelschoolsweetwaterkarenofferingseptembermunicipalsec'sagainstorderprojections

Exhibits & Attached Documents (2)

Extracted insights

Dollar amounts 4
  • $28.00M $28 million $10M–$100M
  • $19.50M $19.5 million $10M–$100M
  • $7.20M $7.2 million $1M–$10M
  • $28K $28,000 $10K–$100K
Entities 8
  • person against michel
  • person against sweetwater
  • person chief financial officer
  • person complaint against karen michel
  • person Karen Marie Michel
  • person karen michel
  • agency Securities and Exchange Commission
  • agency the securities and exchange commission
Triples 85
  • SEC charged Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel
  • SEC charged Sweetwater Union High School District
  • SEC charged Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District misled investors
  • Karen Michel misled investors
  • investors purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • SEC filed complaint against Michel
  • SEC issued order against Sweetwater
  • SEC charged Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District is a San Diego County school district
  • Karen Michel is former Chief Financial Officer of Sweetwater Union High School District
  • SEC alleged misleading investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • SEC filed complaint against Karen Michel
  • SEC issued order against Sweetwater Union High School District
  • Securities and Exchange Commission v. Karen Marie Michel is Case No. 21-cv-01623-L-BGS
  • Securities and Exchange Commission v. Karen Marie Michel filed September 16, 2021
  • Litigation Release No. 25215 dated September 22, 2021
  • SEC charged Sweetwater Union High School District and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • SEC misleading investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • SEC filed Securities and Exchange Commission v. Karen Marie Michel, No. 21-cv-01623-L-BGS (S.D. Cal. filed September 16, 2021)
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misleading investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged Sweetwater Union High School District
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged Karen Michel
  • Karen Michel is Chief Financial Officer
  • Sweetwater Union High School District is San Diego County school district
  • Karen Michel misleading investors
  • investors purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misleading investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged Sweetwater Union High School District and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel, with misleading investors in a $28 million municipal bond offering
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Marie Michel with misleading investors in a $28 million bond offering
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged Sweetwater Union High School District and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel, with misleading investors in a $28 million municipal bond offering
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged Sweetwater Union High School District and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel, with misleading investors in a $28 million bond offering
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged Sweetwater Union High School District
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged Karen Michel
  • Karen Michel is Chief Financial Officer
  • Sweetwater Union High School District is San Diego County school district
  • Karen Michel misleading investors
  • investors purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Sweetwater Union High School District charged with misleading investors in bond offering
  • Karen Marie Michel charged with misleading investors in bond offering
  • Sweetwater Union High School District issued $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Karen Marie Michel served as Chief Financial Officer of Sweetwater Union High School District
  • SEC filed lawsuit against Karen Marie Michel and Sweetwater Union High School District
  • SEC announced charges against Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Marie Michel
  • April 2021 date of misleading statements in bond offering
  • Sweetwater Union High School District misled investors in $28 million municipal bond offering
  • Karen Marie Michel charged with misleading investors
  • SEC charged Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Marie Michel
  • Karen Marie Michel served as Chief Financial Officer of Sweetwater Union High School District
  • SEC filed lawsuit against Karen Marie Michel and Sweetwater Union High School District
  • April 2021 related to misleading disclosures in bond offering
  • The Securities and Exchange Commission charged Sweetwater Union High School District and former CFO Karen Michel
  • Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • Investors purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
  • SEC filed complaint against Karen Michel
  • Litigation Release No. 25215 dated September 22, 2021
  • Securities and Exchange Commission v. Karen Marie Michel filed case No. 21-cv-01623-L-BGS
  • SEC charged Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District is a San Diego County school district
  • Karen Michel is former Chief Financial Officer of Sweetwater Union High School District
  • SEC alleged misleading investors in $28 million municipal bond offering
  • Securities and Exchange Commission filed civil action against Karen Marie Michel
  • Securities and Exchange Commission issued order against Sweetwater Union High School District
  • Securities and Exchange Commission charged San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel
  • Sweetwater Union High School District and Karen Michel misled investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds
Text layers
Extracted body text (3,321c)
SEC Charges School District and Former Executive with Misleading Investors in Bond Offering Litigation Release No. 25215 / September 22, 2021 Securities and Exchange Commission v. Karen Marie Michel, No. 21-cv-01623-L-BGS (S.D. Cal. filed September 16, 2021) The Securities and Exchange Commission today charged a San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel, with misleading investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds. According to the SEC's complaint against Michel and its order against Sweetwater, in April 2018, Sweetwater and Michel provided investors with misleading budget projections that indicated the district could cover its costs and would end the fiscal year with a general fund balance of approximately $19.5 million, when in reality the district was engaged in significant deficit spending and on track to a negative $7.2 million ending fund balance. The order finds that Michel managed the bond offering for the district and was aware of reports showing that the projections were untenable and contradicted by known actual expenses. Nevertheless, as stated in the order, Sweetwater and Michel included the projections in the April 2018 bonds' offering documents and also provided them to a credit rating agency that rated the district, while omitting that the projections were contradicted by internal reports and did not account for actual expenses. Additionally, the complaint alleges that Michel signed multiple certifications falsely attesting to the accuracy and completeness of the information included in the offering documents. The SEC's complaint against Michel, filed in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California, charges her with violating Section 17(a)(3) of the Securities Act of 1933. Without admitting or denying the allegations in the complaint, Michel agreed to settle with the SEC and to be enjoined from future violations of the charged provision as well as from participating in any future municipal securities offerings. She also agreed to pay a $28,000 penalty. The settlement is subject to court approval. Sweetwater also agreed to settle with the SEC and consented, without admitting or denying any findings, to the entry of an SEC order finding that it violated Sections 17(a)(2) and 17(a)(3) of the Securities Act of 1933, and requiring it to engage an independent consultant to evaluate its policies and procedures related to its municipal securities disclosures. For further information about the SEC's enforcement actions involving fraud charges in connection with bond issuances by or on behalf of schools and colleges, see SEC v. Park View School, Inc. (D. Ariz. September 14, 2020), SEC v. Batchelor (N.D. Cal. April 27, 2020), SEC v. Rojas (C.D. Cal. September 19, 2019), and SEC v. Borge (S.D.N.Y. March 28, 2019). The SEC has also brought a number of recent enforcement actions against municipal advisors who provide services to school district issuers. The SEC's investigation was conducted by William T. Salzmann, Jessica A. Adams, Creighton Papier, and Joseph Chimienti of the Public Finance Abuse Unit. The investigation was supervised by Jason H. Lee. The SEC acknowledges the assistance of the San Diego County District Attorney's Office. SEC Complaint
OCR text (3,321c · html-text · 99% conf)
SEC Charges School District and Former Executive with Misleading Investors in Bond Offering Litigation Release No. 25215 / September 22, 2021 Securities and Exchange Commission v. Karen Marie Michel, No. 21-cv-01623-L-BGS (S.D. Cal. filed September 16, 2021) The Securities and Exchange Commission today charged a San Diego County school district, Sweetwater Union High School District, and its former Chief Financial Officer, Karen Michel, with misleading investors who purchased $28 million in municipal bonds. According to the SEC's complaint against Michel and its order against Sweetwater, in April 2018, Sweetwater and Michel provided investors with misleading budget projections that indicated the district could cover its costs and would end the fiscal year with a general fund balance of approximately $19.5 million, when in reality the district was engaged in significant deficit spending and on track to a negative $7.2 million ending fund balance. The order finds that Michel managed the bond offering for the district and was aware of reports showing that the projections were untenable and contradicted by known actual expenses. Nevertheless, as stated in the order, Sweetwater and Michel included the projections in the April 2018 bonds' offering documents and also provided them to a credit rating agency that rated the district, while omitting that the projections were contradicted by internal reports and did not account for actual expenses. Additionally, the complaint alleges that Michel signed multiple certifications falsely attesting to the accuracy and completeness of the information included in the offering documents. The SEC's complaint against Michel, filed in U.S. District Court for the Southern District of California, charges her with violating Section 17(a)(3) of the Securities Act of 1933. Without admitting or denying the allegations in the complaint, Michel agreed to settle with the SEC and to be enjoined from future violations of the charged provision as well as from participating in any future municipal securities offerings. She also agreed to pay a $28,000 penalty. The settlement is subject to court approval. Sweetwater also agreed to settle with the SEC and consented, without admitting or denying any findings, to the entry of an SEC order finding that it violated Sections 17(a)(2) and 17(a)(3) of the Securities Act of 1933, and requiring it to engage an independent consultant to evaluate its policies and procedures related to its municipal securities disclosures. For further information about the SEC's enforcement actions involving fraud charges in connection with bond issuances by or on behalf of schools and colleges, see SEC v. Park View School, Inc. (D. Ariz. September 14, 2020), SEC v. Batchelor (N.D. Cal. April 27, 2020), SEC v. Rojas (C.D. Cal. September 19, 2019), and SEC v. Borge (S.D.N.Y. March 28, 2019). The SEC has also brought a number of recent enforcement actions against municipal advisors who provide services to school district issuers. The SEC's investigation was conducted by William T. Salzmann, Jessica A. Adams, Creighton Papier, and Joseph Chimienti of the Public Finance Abuse Unit. The investigation was supervised by Jason H. Lee. The SEC acknowledges the assistance of the San Diego County District Attorney's Office. SEC Complaint