SEC Announces Settlement with College Savings Plan for Untrue Statements and Ommissions
The SEC settled charges against the Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) for falsely concealing systemic accounting flaws and misappropriation of $505,976 in investor funds by its former director Dale C. Hatch, who transferred $85,000 to personal accounts, resulting in full investor refunds, corrective measures, and a cease-and-desist order, while Hatch faces separate civil fraud charges.
The SEC brought its first-ever enforcement action against a Section 529 plan, settling charges against the Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) for untrue statements and omissions regarding accounting flaws and the misappropriation of $505,976 in investor funds by former director Dale C. Hatch, who transferred $85,000 to his personal accounts. UESP falsely labeled the stolen funds as 'administrative' and claimed investors were unharmed, while failing to disclose operational defects, leading to a cease-and-desist order under Section 17(a)(2) of the Securities Act and a requirement to fully refund all affected investors. The SEC also filed a separate civil suit against Hatch seeking disgorgement, civil penalties, and an injunction, and issued its first-ever investor guide on 529 plans to enhance transparency and disclosure standards.
The SEC announced its first-ever enforcement action against a Section 529 educational savings plan, settling charges against the Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) for making untrue statements and material omissions about systemic accounting flaws and the misappropriation of $505,976 in investor funds by its former director, Dale C. Hatch. Hatch segregated the unallocated funds into undisclosed nominee accounts and transferred $85,000 to his personal bank accounts, while UESP publicly misrepresented the theft as 'administrative' expenses and falsely assured investors they had not been harmed. UESP failed to disclose the operational and accounting defects that enabled the fraud, violating Section 17(a)(2) of the Securities Act of 1933. As part of the settlement, UESP agreed to a cease-and-desist order, fully refunded all affected investors, and committed to correcting its accounting systems—without admitting or denying guilt. The SEC also filed a separate civil complaint against Hatch seeking disgorgement, civil money penalties, and an injunction for securities fraud. In response to this landmark case, the SEC issued its first-ever investor guide on 529 plans to help families understand disclosures, fees, tax implications, and risks associated with state-sponsored college savings plans. The Commission emphasized that while UESP cooperated in the investigation, the case underscored the critical need for transparency in tax-advantaged savings vehicles governed by state agencies.
Exhibits & Attached Documents (1)
Extracted insights
- $506K $505,976 $100K–$1M
- $85K $85,000 $10K–$100K
- person dale c. hatch
- person investor accounts
- agency sec's salt lake district office
- agency Securities and Exchange Commission
- SEC announced settlement with Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP)
- Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) made untrue statements and omissions concerning errors in systems of operation and accounting methods
- Dale C. Hatch misappropriated $505,976 of unallocated participant funds
- Dale C. Hatch transferred to personal bank accounts $85,000
- SEC filed civil action against Dale C. Hatch
- Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) administers Section 529 educational savings plan for Utah
- Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) ordered to cease and desist from violations of Section 17(a)(2) of the Securities Act of 1933
- Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) ordered to fully refund investor accounts
- Kenneth D. Israel, Jr. is District Administrator of SEC's Salt Lake District Office
- Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) has repaid investors in full
SEC ANNOUNCES SETTLEMENT WITH COLLEGE SAVINGS PLAN FOR UNTRUE STATEMENTS AND OMISSIONS FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE 2005-108 First-Ever Case Prompts Commission Guidance on Section 529 Educational Savings Plans Washington, D.C., Aug. 4, 2005-The Securities and Exchange Commission today announced a settled cease-and-desist proceeding against the Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) for untrue statements and omissions by the UESP concerning errors in its systems of operation and its method of accounting for investor transactions. The UESP administers a Section 529 educational savings plan for Utah. In announcing its first ever charges against a Section 529 savings plan, the SEC also issued an investor guide that explains the basic information investors should know before they start saving for college. The guide discusses the different types of college savings plans, including their disclosures, tax implications and their fees and expenses. While conducting an investigation of Dale C. Hatch, its former director, the USEP discovered flaws in its system of operation and accounting practices that failed to fully allocate investor gains and losses to investor accounts. The UESP also determined that certain of those unallocated gains had been misappropriated by Hatch. However, the UESP publicly mischaracterized the misappropriated funds as "administrative" and falsely claimed that investors had not been harmed. The UESP also provided inadequate disclosure about the flaws in its operations and accounting practices. In settling the proceeding, the Commission ordered the UESP to fully refund investor accounts and undertake specific measures to correct the defects of its system. The Commission also ordered the UESP to cease and desist from further violations of Section 17(a)(2) of the Securities Act of 1933. Separately, the Commission has filed a civil action against Hatch in federal court alleging he violated the securities laws by segregating $505,976 of unallocated participant funds into his own undisclosed nominee UESP accounts and transferring $85,000 of those funds to his personal bank accounts. That action seeks an injunction from future antifraud violations, disgorgement and civil money penalties. "The USEP discovered its system for recording and accounting for investor transactions was flawed, but failed to disclose some of those defects and the risks posed to investors," said Kenneth D. Israel, Jr., District Administrator of SEC's Salt Lake District Office. "The Commission's action ensures the return of investor funds, that UESP will fix its system, and that material facts related to investor transactions and earnings will be disclosed." The UESP consented to the entry of the Commission's order without admitting or denying the Commission's findings. In determining to accept the settlement, the Commission considered the UESP's cooperation in the SEC investigation. The UESP has already repaid its investors in full. A 529 plan is a tax-advantaged savings plan designed to encourage saving for future college costs. 529 plans, legally known as "qualified tuition plans," are sponsored by states, state agencies, or educational institutions and are authorized by Section 529 of the Internal Revenue Code. The Commission's new guidance explains the many differences between 529 plans, which vary from state to state, including their disclosures and tax implications. "The best way to make an informed decision about any college savings plan is to understand its terms," said SEC investor education director Susan Ferris Wyderko. "While our new guide is a good place to start, a college savings plan's disclosure documents remain required reading." The Commission's investor guide on Section 529 education savings plans is available at www.sec.gov/investor/pubs/intro529.htm See also: Administrative Proceeding For more information about the UESP settlement, contact: Kenneth D. Israel, Jr. District Administrator (801) 524-5796 For more information about the investor guide, contact: Gerri Walsh Investor Education and Assistance Deputy Director (202) 551-6500 http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2005-108.htm Home | Previous Page Modified: 08/04/2005
SEC ANNOUNCES SETTLEMENT WITH COLLEGE SAVINGS PLAN FOR UNTRUE STATEMENTS AND OMISSIONS FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE 2005-108 First-Ever Case Prompts Commission Guidance on Section 529 Educational Savings Plans Washington, D.C., Aug. 4, 2005-The Securities and Exchange Commission today announced a settled cease-and-desist proceeding against the Utah Educational Savings Plan Trust (UESP) for untrue statements and omissions by the UESP concerning errors in its systems of operation and its method of accounting for investor transactions. The UESP administers a Section 529 educational savings plan for Utah. In announcing its first ever charges against a Section 529 savings plan, the SEC also issued an investor guide that explains the basic information investors should know before they start saving for college. The guide discusses the different types of college savings plans, including their disclosures, tax implications and their fees and expenses. While conducting an investigation of Dale C. Hatch, its former director, the USEP discovered flaws in its system of operation and accounting practices that failed to fully allocate investor gains and losses to investor accounts. The UESP also determined that certain of those unallocated gains had been misappropriated by Hatch. However, the UESP publicly mischaracterized the misappropriated funds as "administrative" and falsely claimed that investors had not been harmed. The UESP also provided inadequate disclosure about the flaws in its operations and accounting practices. In settling the proceeding, the Commission ordered the UESP to fully refund investor accounts and undertake specific measures to correct the defects of its system. The Commission also ordered the UESP to cease and desist from further violations of Section 17(a)(2) of the Securities Act of 1933. Separately, the Commission has filed a civil action against Hatch in federal court alleging he violated the securities laws by segregating $505,976 of unallocated participant funds into his own undisclosed nominee UESP accounts and transferring $85,000 of those funds to his personal bank accounts. That action seeks an injunction from future antifraud violations, disgorgement and civil money penalties. "The USEP discovered its system for recording and accounting for investor transactions was flawed, but failed to disclose some of those defects and the risks posed to investors," said Kenneth D. Israel, Jr., District Administrator of SEC's Salt Lake District Office. "The Commission's action ensures the return of investor funds, that UESP will fix its system, and that material facts related to investor transactions and earnings will be disclosed." The UESP consented to the entry of the Commission's order without admitting or denying the Commission's findings. In determining to accept the settlement, the Commission considered the UESP's cooperation in the SEC investigation. The UESP has already repaid its investors in full. A 529 plan is a tax-advantaged savings plan designed to encourage saving for future college costs. 529 plans, legally known as "qualified tuition plans," are sponsored by states, state agencies, or educational institutions and are authorized by Section 529 of the Internal Revenue Code. The Commission's new guidance explains the many differences between 529 plans, which vary from state to state, including their disclosures and tax implications. "The best way to make an informed decision about any college savings plan is to understand its terms," said SEC investor education director Susan Ferris Wyderko. "While our new guide is a good place to start, a college savings plan's disclosure documents remain required reading." The Commission's investor guide on Section 529 education savings plans is available at www.sec.gov/investor/pubs/intro529.htm See also: Administrative Proceeding For more information about the UESP settlement, contact: Kenneth D. Israel, Jr. District Administrator (801) 524-5796 For more information about the investor guide, contact: Gerri Walsh Investor Education and Assistance Deputy Director (202) 551-6500 http://www.sec.gov/news/press/2005-108.htm Home | Previous Page Modified: 08/04/2005